Difference Between Primary Group and Secondary Group Notes Study Material
Different Sociologists have classified groups in different ways. The chief bases of these classifications of groups are functions scope and stability George Simmel, Von Weise and Bekare have taken numbers as a basis. Difference Between Primary Group and Secondary Group Notes Study Material. Tonnies has taken social interaction as a basis. Lovie and Malinowski have preferred age, sei and other signs and action. Similarly, the group have been classified based on size duration and choice.
Bogardus has classified groups into the following types.
- In formal, Förmal and Bureaucratic.
- Voluntary and involuntary.
- Genetic and Congregate.
- Primary and Secondary.
- Disjunctive and Overlapping.
- Social, Pseudo-social, Anti-Social, Pro-Social and Socialized.
Some Other Important Classifications of Groups are as Following Types of Difference Between Primary Group and Secondary Group Notes Study Material Out Group and In Group:
Cooley’s classification
- Primary Groups: In which there are face-to-face, strong and cooperative relations between the persons such as a family.
- Secondary Groups: Where strong personal and warin relations found as in political parties.”
Summer’s Classification:
In-group and Out-group: Summer classified between ‘in-groups’ and ‘out-groups’. The individual belongs to a number of groups which are by ‘in-groups’; all other groups to which does not belong are his ‘out-group’.All groups tend to maintain their boundaries by developing a strong sense of the distinction between the ‘we’ of the group and ‘they’ who are outside the group.
In-group: The term ‘in-group’ was used by W.G. Summer in ‘Folkways’. The Family, The Tribe, and The College to which a person belongs are his in-groups’. The members of an ‘in-group’ feel that their personaly welfare is in some way or other bound up with that of the other members of the group. There is always a considerable degree of sympathy. In their relationship towards each other they display cooperation, goodwill mutual help and respect for one another’s rights. Thus ‘in-group’ is any association either primary or secondary towards which. We have a sense of solidarity, Loyalty, friendliness and cooperation. The members of the in-group signify their unity by the word ‘we’ Sumner also said that ‘ethnocentrism’ is a characteristic of the ‘in-group’.
Out-Group: The ‘Out-group’ consists of those persons, whether formally organized or not, toward whom we feel a sense of indifference, avoidance, disgust, competition, or outright conflict. The antipathy, which may range in intensity from a mildly supercilious attitude to intense hatred.’ The distinction between- ‘in-group’ and out-group is usually expressed in the contrast between ‘we’ and ‘they’ or ‘other’
Miller’s Classification:
- Vertical
- Horizontal
Gidding’s Classification:
- Public.
- Private.
And
- Genetic.
- congregate.
Elwood’s Classification:
- Sanctioned.
- Unsanctioned.
Gillin and Gillen’s Classification:
- Based on blood relationship.
- Based on physical traits.
- Based on situation proximity.
- Based on cultural interests.
Word’s Classification:
- Voluntary.
- Involuntary.
Classifying groups is a difficult task. In this connection, Cuber has rightly written, “Sociologists have devoted a great deal of effort to the difficult problem of classifying groups into types. At first, thought this would seem easy to do perhaps after further reflection. It will be found to present numerous difficulties.
Characteristics of Social Group
-
The members of a group are related to each other.
Simply a gathering of persons can not be called a group. The members of the group should be interrelated. This social relation is called s group. Cuber has written, “A group is any number of human beings in reciprocal communication.” Maciver and some other sociologists have also admitted that social relations are the fundamentals of the social group.
-
Group implies a feeling of Unity:
A feeling of unity is essential for every group. Through such feelings, members of a group treat each other as their own and a sense of sympathy between them develops.
-
Members of a group have a sense of We-feeling:
In a sense, we feel the members of a group help each other in performing their duties, and they defend collectively against harmful powers. They treat others as outsiders and try to make their group prosperous and self-sufficient.
-
The interests, ideals and values of the group members are common:
A group includes those persons who are related to each other in such, a way that they should be treated as one. Fore ie the interests, ideals and values of the persons of a group should tend to be common because this similarity promotes unity.
-
There is a Similarity in behaviour in a group:
As the interests, ideals and values of the persons of a group are common, Similarly, the behaviour of the members also tends to be similar. A social group is not merely a group of persons, but it is a continuation of their behaviour.
-
Control of the group over the actions of members:
The main reason behind the similarity of behaviour in the group is that the actions of the members are controlled by the group. In each group, there are some customs, norms and producers which are acceptable to everyone and the members of the group have to obey them. Whenever these are neglected, the group gives punishment. In this way, everyone has to obey the social norms. In fact, without some norms, the existence of group life is practically impossible.
-
The members of a group are affected by its characteristics:
Each group possesses some special characteristics which distinguish it from similar and dissimilar groups. These characteristics affect the members constituting the groups. This effect may be different for different persons, but still, all the members are affected by the group.
-
Meaning and Definitions of Primary group:
Explain the meaning of the ‘Primary Group’ Sociologist C.H. Cooley has written, “By primary group I mean those characterised by inmate’s face to face association and co-operation.
The result of intimate association .. is a certain fusion of individualities in a common whole, the one’s very self for many purposes at least the common life and purpose of the group. Perhaps the simplest way of describing this wholeness is by saving that it is ‘We’, it involves the sort of sympathy and mutual identification for which ‘we’ is the natural expression,” According to Cooley, Difference Between Primary Group and Secondary Group Notes Study Material the best examples of primary groups are family, a group of children, Playmates and neighbourhood or the village, etc. These groups affect the life of human beings more vitally than other groups, Regarding Playgroups.
Maciver has written “It is the group through which as playmates and comrades we give first creative expression to our social impulses. It is the breeding ground of our mores, the hurse of our loyalties. It is the first and face group that is primary in our lives.’ generally remains the chief focus of our social satisfaction. In these respects, the face group is primary in our lives.
Characteristics of Primary Groups:
For a better understanding of the Primary groups, it is necessary to understand their characteristics. Some of these characteristics are internal and some of them are external.
Physical closeness among members:
It is necessary for a primary group that the members constituting it should be physically close to each other. It will be very difficult to exchange thoughts or to help each other if they are not physically close. The members of the primary groups are very closely related. Therefore Physical closeness is essential for them.
Small Size:
The size of the primary group should be so small that the desired relations can be developed. Intimacy diminishes when the number of persons is increased in a class, family, team or other group. On the other hand, the smaller the size of the family the greater the intimacy there is. If the audience is in excess, everybody cannot see the speaker and also can not listen to him.
Stability:
To promote closeness in a primary group, it should be stable to some extent. New friends increase and old ones decrease if a person tends to change places too often.
Continuity:
Therefore, continuity in relations is necessary for the members of the primary group. By meeting frequently, and by exchanging thoughts, intimacy increases. When this chain is broken, the relations do not remain so fast.
Common aims among the members:
Members of a primary group have common aims and purposes. In a primary group like a family etc. every member’s pleasure and pain are shared by the whole family group and all the members work for some common aims.
Relations are ends in themselves:
The relations of the members of a primary group are not based on personal interests. These relations are ends in themselves. These provide mental pleasure and contentment to both parties. Family relations are of this nature.
The relations of the members are spontaneous:
As the relations of the members of the primary groups end in themselves, they are also spontaneous. There is nothing like compulsion in the pressure between them. Every member of the group naturally feels intimacy for others.
Members have personal relations:
‘Members of primary groups have personal relations and this is why the gap of one member’s absence is not killed completely by the other. After the death of a wife, a person may marry again, as the memory of the first wife does not end. Kingsley Davis has rightly written. “A new personal relationship can be established, an old one can be abandoned, but no substitution can be made of one individual for another in the same relationship.”
Relations of the members are inclusive:
The relations of the members of a primary group are inclusive, and their whole personality takes an active part in these relations.
Maximum control on the members:
- Because of the intimacy, spontaneity, physical closeness, stability and the small size of the group, all the members of a primary group know each other very well, and it is difficult to separate the affairs of any member from the others. Therefore, there is maximum control of the group on the affairs of the members of the group.
Importance of Primary Group
The reason behind the foundation of the social structure of the primary group is their advantages. The members of the groups get many advantages that they can not achieve through their actions. From the point of view of an individual, the main points regarding the importance of a primary group are as follows :
Development of Personality:
Freud, Adler and other psychologists have maintained that the personality of a child is developed in the family and playmate group and it does not change appreciably afterwards, only it develops. Thus the development of personality depends, in most cases, upon the primary groups.
Increase in Efficiency:
With the development meant of personality in primary groups, efficiency is also increased. Persons of a group get help, inspiration and cooperation from the others. In a family, a person works so efficiently for his children that he can never work with such efficiency for himself.
Satisfaction of Psychological needs:
Primary groups satisfy many psychological needs of individuals. They provide a sense of contentment and security to the persons and satisfy their desires of loving and being loved. In the Primary group, a person gets the benefits of companionship, sympathy, and exchange of thoughts and satisfies most of the psychological needs.
Secondary Group meaning and Definitions:
Defining a secondary group. Landis has written, ” Secondary groups represent that Cold World’ into which parents in rural communities have always thought of their young people going when they leave home secondary groups are those that are relatively casual and impersonal in their relationship. Difference Between Primary Group and Secondary Group Notes Study Material. Because secondary groups make only: specialised demands on the person, they receive attention.
Relationships in them are usually competitive rather than mutually helpful.”
Definitions of Secondary Group:
Ogburn and Nimkoff have defined secondary groups by saying, The groups which provide experience lacking in intimacy are called secondary groups.”
They are constituted for some purposes and aims after achieving which, they are no more required. Relations with them are indirect short and temporary.
Paul Lands has called the secondary group representative of the cold world. The worth of the relations in primary groups can not be found in the indirect relations in secondary groups.
The relations in the secondary group are of “touch and go’ type. Moreover, the behaviour in the secondary group is formal. This type of ‘cold behaviour’ can be seen among members of an office. The members do not have an interest in the pleasure and pain, and problems of others.
Characteristics of Secondary Group:
The characteristics of a secondary group through light on its nature. The chief characteristics are as follows.
- Position of a person depends upon his role: In the secondary group, the position of every person depends upon his role, the persons are not treated based on their births.
- Individuality in Persons: Individuality develops in the persons in the secondary groups because their relations are based on self-interest. After satisfying their interest, they are no longer interested in the group.
- Self-dependence among members: Therefore, the members of a secondary group are self-dependent. They have to safeguard their interests themselves. Because of the big size of the group, the relations are indirect.
Difference between of Primary and Secondary Group
- The size of a primary group is small while that of a secondary group is big.
- The relations in primary groups are close and direct while in secondary groups, these are indirect and formal.
- In primary groups, the purposes and aims are the same for all members and the persons take other’s interests as their own. In secondary groups, the aims and purposes are not the same. Therefore, tries to fulfil his interest.
- In primary groups, the relations are inclusive and this is why the absence of one person can not be fulfilled by another, inclusiveness of relations is not found in the secondary groups and so a person can very easily take the place of any other person.
- Primary groups are the foundation stones of society. Secondary groups are not so important.
- Primary groups are generally found in old and rural societies. The secondary groups are generally found in urban areas.
- Primary groups do not include other groups in them. Secondary groups may include several groups because of their big size.
- The primary. group is concerned with the total personality of a person and develops his personality. The secondary group is concerned with a particular aspect of the personality and it develops only that aspect.
- Qualities like love, sympathy, mutual help, etc. Flourish in the primary groups while secondary groups promote self-interest and individuality.
- There is a fixed routine in the primary groups which is controlled by the aged persons and the rules of which have to be obeyed by all the members compulsorily. There is lesser control over the affairs of a person in the secondary group and these are controlled by Police, Jail, government, courts etc.